[Epitaph on Mrs Clerke]
You can add notes or queries to any part of the poetic text by simply clicking on the line in question and filling in the annotations form with your details. All contributions will be submitted to the editor in the first instance for review.
[Epitaph on Mrs Clerke]
Expanding the poem lines (
) shows the results of a computationally facilitated analysis of the text. These results should be considered as a basis for deeper interpretative enquiry such as can be found in the notes and queries.
[Epitaph on Mrs Clerke] Skip to next line
Metrical foot type: iambic (-+)
Metrical foot number: tetrameter (4 feet)
Rhyme scheme: aa
Rhyme (stanza position): pair (aabb)
Syllable pattern: 8
Stanza: couplet (2 lines)
Genre(s): epitaph
Theme(s): death
Notation symbols: | (foot boundary), || (caesura), / (metrical line boundary), + (metrically prominent), - (metrically non-prominent)
Metre: -+|-+|-+|-+/ | Syllables: 8
Metre: -+|-+|-+|-+/ | Syllables: 8
Metre: -+|-+|-+|-+/ | Syllables: 8
Metre: -+|-+|-+|-+/ | Syllables: 8
Metre: -+|-+|-+|-+/ | Syllables: 8
Metre: -+|-+|-+|-+/ | Syllables: 8
Metre: -+|-+|-+|-+/ | Syllables: 8
Metre: -+|-+|-+|-+/ | Syllables: 8
Metre: -+|-+|-+|-+/ | Syllables: 8
Metre: -+|-+|-+|-+/ | Syllables: 8
Metre: -+|-+|-+|-+/ | Syllables: 8
Metre: -+|-+|-+|-+/ | Syllables: 8
Metre: -+|-+|-+|-+/ | Syllables: 8
Metre: -+|-+|-+|-+/ | Syllables: 8
Metre: -+|-+|-+|-+/ | Syllables: 8
Metre: -+|-+|-+|-+/ | Syllables: 8
Expanding the poem lines () shows notes and queries taken from various critical editions of Gray's works, as well as those contributed by users of the Archive. There are 20 textual and 17 explanatory notes/queries.
[Epitaph on Mrs Clerke] 6 Explanatory, 6 Textual Skip to next line
Title/Paratext] "[This was the wife of [...]" E. Gosse, 1884.
"[This was the wife of Dr. John Clerke, an early college friend of Gray's, and afterwards a physician at Epsom. The lady died in childbirth, April 27, 1757, and was buried in the church of Beckenham, Kent. - Ed.]"
The Works of Thomas Gray: In Prose and Verse. Ed. by Edmund Gosse, in four vols. London: MacMillan and Co., 1884, vol. i, 125.Title/Paratext] "This epitaph is on a [...]" J. Bradshaw, 1891.
"This epitaph is on a mural tablet of slate and marble in the Church at Beckenham, Kent. The inscription is—
"Jane Clarkeand then follow the verses in two columns.
Died April 27, 1757. Aged 31."
The epitaph was first printed in the "Gentleman's Magazine" for October, 1774."The Poetical Works of Thomas Gray: English and Latin. Edited with an introduction, life, notes and a bibliography by John Bradshaw. The Aldine edition of the British poets series. London: George Bell and sons, 1891, 255.
Title/Paratext] "Mason's note is: "This Lady, [...]" J. Bradshaw, 1891.
"Mason's note is: "This Lady, the wife of Dr. Clarke, Physician at Epsom, died April 27, 1757, and is buried in the Church of Beckenham, Kent."
Subsequent editors have repeated his note, but the fact that the
epitaph is on a tablet in the church, and that it appeared in print before
Mason's edition of Gray, has not been recorded before. Clarke was a college
friend of Gray's."
Title/Paratext] "This epitaph is on a [...]" D.C. Tovey, 1922 [1st ed. 1898].
"This epitaph is on a mural tablet of slate and marble in the Church at Beckenham, Kent. The inscription is:
Died March 27, 1757. Aged 31. (Bradshaw.)
Title/Paratext] "[The epitaph is on a [...]" A.L. Poole/L. Whibley, 1950 [1st ed. 1919].
"[The epitaph is on a mural tablet of slate and marble in the church at Beckenham in Kent. A copy (with some variants) was sent in a letter to Bedingfield, January 31, 1758. The inscription is -
Died April 27, 1757. Aged 31.]"
Title/Paratext] "First printed in Fawkes and [...]" H.W. Starr/J.R. Hendrickson, 1966.
"First printed in Fawkes and Woty, The Poetical Calendar, 2nd ed., London: Dryden Leach, 1763, viii. 121. The text used here is that inscribed in St. George's parish church at Beckenham, Kent (BK), but on the tablet (examined by the editors and rechecked by the Revd. T. C. Hammond, Rector of Beckenham) the inscription is cut in capital letters throughout and there are no marks of punctuation. Consequently, lower-case letters and punctuation have been supplied. The only holograph MS. is the letter to Bedingfield (T & W no. 266), 31 Jan. 1758, Huntington Library MS. HM 21912 (Bed)."
The Complete Poems of Thomas Gray: English, Latin and Greek. Edited by Herbert W. Starr and J. R. Hendrickson. Oxford: Oxford UP, 1966, 52.Title/Paratext] "Title: In B[eckenham,] K[ent] the [...]" H.W. Starr/J.R. Hendrickson, 1966.
"Title: In B[eckenham,] K[ent] the inscription is headed JANE CLERKE / DIED APRIL XXVII, MDCCLVII. AGED XXXI."
The Complete Poems of Thomas Gray: English, Latin and Greek. Edited by Herbert W. Starr and J. R. Hendrickson. Oxford: Oxford UP, 1966, 52.Title/Paratext] "Jane Clerke (1726-57), the wife [...]" H.W. Starr/J.R. Hendrickson, 1966.
"Jane Clerke (1726-57), the wife of John Clerke (1717-90), Fellow of Pembroke and later a physician at Epsom, died in childbirth, according to Gosse (although Tovey questions the circumstance). Her husband presumably asked Gray to write the epitaph."
The Complete Poems of Thomas Gray: English, Latin and Greek. Edited by Herbert W. Starr and J. R. Hendrickson. Oxford: Oxford UP, 1966, 228.Title/Paratext] "The first printing of the [...]" R. Lonsdale, 1969.
"The first printing of the poem has not hitherto been noted. It appeared in the Gentleman's Mag. xxix 485, for Oct. 1759, entitled (not accurately), 'An Epitaph, copied from a Tomb-stone in a Country Church Yard'. (This text contains one variant: 'thus' for 'yet' in l. 11.) It was accompanied by a Latin translation, which has not otherwise been traced in print, although it may be connected with a copy of the epitaph, with an unfinished Latin translation, in an unidentified hand found among Richard Hurd's papers (see Correspondence of Hurd and Mason, ed. Pearce and Whibley, 1932, p. 168). The only other occasion on which the poem was printed in G[ray].'s lifetime was in the Poetical Calendar (2nd edn, 1763) viii 121. It was reprinted in the New Foundling Hospital for Wit (1772) vi 76-7, and in the Gentleman's Mag. xliv (1774) 487, before Mason collected it in the Poems p. 61, in 1775. Wordsworth, Prose Works, ed. A. B. Grosart (1876) ii 66-7, thought its first 6 lines 'vague and languid' but praised the 'latter part' as 'almost the only instance among the metrical epitaphs in our language of the last century, which I remember, of affecting thoughts rising naturally and keeping themselves pure from vicious diction; and therefore retaining their appropriate power over the mind'."
The Poems of Thomas Gray, William Collins, Oliver Goldsmith. Edited by Roger Lonsdale. Longman Annotated English Poets Series. London and Harlow: Longmans, 1969, 208.Title/Paratext] "Written not long before 31 [...]" R. Lonsdale, 1969.
"Written not long before 31 Jan. 1758, when G[ray]. sent it in a letter to Edward Bedingfield (Corresp ii 560): 'I will not send you the Sonnet you mention [presumably that on Richard West], but here is something else full as bad, only as it is just wrote, I send it to you. it is an epitaph on the Wife of a Friend of mine.' John Clerke (1717-90) had been a contemporary of G. at Peterhouse, became a Fellow in 1740 and practised as a physician for many years at Epsom. His father had been Rector of Beckenham in Kent and G.'s epitaph was duly inscribed on a mural tablet of slate and stone in St George's Church, Beckenham. Mrs Clerke had died in childbirth at the age of 31 on 27 April 1757."
The Poems of Thomas Gray, William Collins, Oliver Goldsmith. Edited by Roger Lonsdale. Longman Annotated English Poets Series. London and Harlow: Longmans, 1969, 207/208.Title/Paratext] "Gray wrote this poem not [...]" J. Reeves, 1973.
"Gray wrote this poem not later than 1758 and described it as 'an epitaph on the Wife of a Friend of mine'. This friend was John Clerke, a contemporary of Gray's at Peterhouse. Mrs Clerke had died in childbirth in 1757."
The Complete English Poems of Thomas Gray. Edited with an Introduction and Notes by James Reeves. The Poetry Bookshelf series. London: Heinemann; New York: Barnes & Noble, 1973, 115.Title/Paratext] "Written between the death of [...]" J. Heath-Stubbs, 1981.
"Written between the death of Mrs Clerke in April 1757 and Jan. 1758, when Gray sent a copy of it to Edward Bedingfield. Mrs Clerke, who died in childbirth, at the age of 31, was the wife of John Clerke, who had been a contemporary of Gray at Peterhouse. Gray's poem is inscribed on her tombstone in Beckenham churchyard, Kent, where John Clerke's father had been rector. The poem was first printed in The Gentleman's Magazine in 1759."
Thomas Gray: Selected Poems. Ed. by John Heath-Stubbs. Manchester: Carcanet New Press Ltd., 1981, 82/83.1.3-6 this ... weeps,] "This was a common poetical [...]" J. Bradshaw, 1891.
"This was a common poetical phrase last century in speaking of monuments to the dead."
The Poetical Works of Thomas Gray: English and Latin. Edited with an introduction, life, notes and a bibliography by John Bradshaw. The Aldine edition of the British poets series. London: George Bell and sons, 1891, 255-256.1.4 silent] "little Variant[] [...] from the [...]" A.L. Poole/L. Whibley, 1950 [1st ed. 1919].
"little Variant[] [...] from the Bedingfield MS."
The Poems of Gray and Collins. Edited by Austin Lane Poole. Revised by Leonard Whibley. Third edition. Oxford editions of standard authors series. London: Oxford UP, 1937, reprinted 1950 [1st ed. 1919], 177.1.4 silent] "little Bed[ingfield MS.]." H.W. Starr/J.R. Hendrickson, 1966.
"little Bed[ingfield MS.]."
The Complete Poems of Thomas Gray: English, Latin and Greek. Edited by Herbert W. Starr and J. R. Hendrickson. Oxford: Oxford UP, 1966, 52.1.4 silent] "little Bedingfield." R. Lonsdale, 1969.
"little Bedingfield."
The Poems of Thomas Gray, William Collins, Oliver Goldsmith. Edited by Roger Lonsdale. Longman Annotated English Poets Series. London and Harlow: Longmans, 1969, 208.1.5-6 marble weeps,] "Commenting on the phrase 'weeping [...]" R. Lonsdale, 1969.
"Commenting on the phrase 'weeping Vaults' in Pope, Windsor Forest 302, Gilbert Wakefield described it as 'A puerile conceit, from the dew, which runs down stone and metals in damp weather', and cited Virgil, Georgics i 480: et maestum inlacrimat templis ebur aeraque sudant (in temples the ivory weeps in sorrow, and bronzes sweat). Cp. Congreve, The Mourning Muse of Alexis 85: 'The marble weeps'; Pope, Epitaph on Duke of Buckingham 5: 'this weeping marble', and 'Here o'er the Martyr-King the Marble weeps', Windsor Forest 313; and 'While o'er her Grave the Marble Statue weeps', John Dart, Westminster Abbey (1723) I xx."
The Poems of Thomas Gray, William Collins, Oliver Goldsmith. Edited by Roger Lonsdale. Longman Annotated English Poets Series. London and Harlow: Longmans, 1969, 208.2.1-7 A ... sleeps:] "'The virgin's part, the mother [...]" R. Lonsdale, 1969.
"'The virgin's part, the mother and the wife', Waller, Thyrsis and Galatea 25; 'A wife, a mistress and a friend in one', Dryden, Epitaph on Lady Whitmore 2; 'The tender sister, daughter, friend and wife', Pope, Epistle to Jervas 52."
The Poems of Thomas Gray, William Collins, Oliver Goldsmith. Edited by Roger Lonsdale. Longman Annotated English Poets Series. London and Harlow: Longmans, 1969, 208.4.1-3 The ... virtues] "Each peaceful Virtue Variant[] [...] A.L. Poole/L. Whibley, 1950 [1st ed. 1919].
"Each peaceful Virtue Variant[] [...] from the Bedingfield MS."
The Poems of Gray and Collins. Edited by Austin Lane Poole. Revised by Leonard Whibley. Third edition. Oxford editions of standard authors series. London: Oxford UP, 1937, reprinted 1950 [1st ed. 1919], 177.4.1-3 The ... virtues] "Each peaceful Virtue Bed[ingfield MS.]." H.W. Starr/J.R. Hendrickson, 1966.
"Each peaceful Virtue Bed[ingfield MS.]."
The Complete Poems of Thomas Gray: English, Latin and Greek. Edited by Herbert W. Starr and J. R. Hendrickson. Oxford: Oxford UP, 1966, 52.4.1-3 The ... virtues] "Each peaceful Virtue Bedingfield." R. Lonsdale, 1969.
"Each peaceful Virtue Bedingfield."
The Poems of Thomas Gray, William Collins, Oliver Goldsmith. Edited by Roger Lonsdale. Longman Annotated English Poets Series. London and Harlow: Longmans, 1969, 209.6.2-3 soft humanity] "Mitford cites lines from Dryden [...]" J. Bradshaw, 1891.
"Mitford cites lines from Dryden and Pope in which this phrase occurs."
The Poetical Works of Thomas Gray: English and Latin. Edited with an introduction, life, notes and a bibliography by John Bradshaw. The Aldine edition of the British poets series. London: George Bell and sons, 1891, 256.6.2-3 soft humanity] "Mitford quotes: [''If Science raised [...]" D.C. Tovey, 1922 [1st ed. 1898].
"Mitford quotes:
[''If Science raised her head]Pope, Epitaph on General Withers.
And soft Humanity that from rebellion fled.''
Dryden, Threnodia Augustalis, st. XII.
''Bred to the rules of soft humanity.''
Dryden, All for Love, II. i.
''[O born to arms! O worth in youth approved!]But perhaps in the first example the expression refers to the liberal arts, literature, 'the humanities' as the Scotch say; whilst in the others, as in Gray, it stands for the gentle courtesies of life."Gray's English Poems, Original and Translated from the Norse and Welsh. Edited by Duncan C. Tovey. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1922 [1st ed. 1898], 234/235.
O soft humanity, in age beloved!''
6.2-3 soft humanity] "Used by Dryden, Threnodia Augustalis [...]" R. Lonsdale, 1969.
"Used by Dryden, Threnodia Augustalis 350 and All for Love II i; Pope, Epitaph on General Withers 4."
The Poems of Thomas Gray, William Collins, Oliver Goldsmith. Edited by Roger Lonsdale. Longman Annotated English Poets Series. London and Harlow: Longmans, 1969, 209.7.1 - 10.6 In ... woe:] "''To hide her cares her [...]" E. Gosse, 1884.
"''To hide her cares her only art,The Works of Thomas Gray: In Prose and Verse. Ed. by Edmund Gosse, in four vols. London: MacMillan and Co., 1884, vol. i, 126/127.
Her pleasure, pleasures to impart,
In ling'ring pain, in death resign'd
Her latest agony of mind
Was felt for him, who could not save
His all from an untimely grave.'' - MS."
7.1 - 10.6 In ... woe:] "Mitford gives the six following [...]" J. Bradshaw, 1891.
"Mitford gives the six following lines as in a manuscript copy instead of lines 7 to 10 as finally decided on:—
"To hide her cares her only art,The Poetical Works of Thomas Gray: English and Latin. Edited with an introduction, life, notes and a bibliography by John Bradshaw. The Aldine edition of the British poets series. London: George Bell and sons, 1891, 256.
Her pleasure, pleasures to impart,
In ling'ring pain, in death resigned,
Her latest agony of mind
Was felt for him, who could not save
His all from an untimely grave.""
7.1 - 10.6 In ... woe:] "V. L. after l. 6 [...]" D.C. Tovey, 1922 [1st ed. 1898].
"V. L. after l. 6 in place of the four next:
''To hide her cares her only art,Gray's English Poems, Original and Translated from the Norse and Welsh. Edited by Duncan C. Tovey. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1922 [1st ed. 1898], 235.
Her pleasure, pleasures to impart,
In ling'ring pain, in death resign'd,
Her latest agony of mind
Was felt for him, who could not save
His All from an untimely grave.'' Mason."
7.1 - 8.7 In ... behind.] "In the wife's solicitude about [...]" D.C. Tovey, 1922 [1st ed. 1898].
"In the wife's solicitude about her husband's pain, as Gray expresses it in the text,
''In agony, in death resign'dthere is such an allusiveness as the difference of circumstances permitted to the words of Arria to Paetus, when she hands him the sword, in Martial (i. 14)
She felt the wound she left behind,''
''Si qua fides, volnus, quod feci non dolet, inquit,Gray's English Poems, Original and Translated from the Norse and Welsh. Edited by Duncan C. Tovey. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1922 [1st ed. 1898], 235.
Sed quod tu facies, hoc mihi Paete dolet.''
['' 'Tis not the wound that I have made, said she,
But that which thou wilt make, that paineth me.'']"
7.1 - 10.6 In ... woe:] "Variant[] [...] from the Bedingfield [...]" A.L. Poole/L. Whibley, 1950 [1st ed. 1919].
"Variant[] [...] from the Bedingfield MS. Mason, in a note to the poem, gives the following lines as a MS. variation 'after line 6, in the place of the four next'.
To hide her cares her only art,The Poems of Gray and Collins. Edited by Austin Lane Poole. Revised by Leonard Whibley. Third edition. Oxford editions of standard authors series. London: Oxford UP, 1937, reprinted 1950 [1st ed. 1919], 177.
Her pleasure, pleasures to impart,
In ling'ring pain, in death resign'd,
Her latest agony of mind
Was felt for him, who could not save
His All from an untimely grave:"
7.1 - 10.6 In ... woe:] "To hide her cares her [...]" H.W. Starr/J.R. Hendrickson, 1966.
"To hide her cares her only art,Bed[ingfield MS.], also noted as variant in M[ason]."The Complete Poems of Thomas Gray: English, Latin and Greek. Edited by Herbert W. Starr and J. R. Hendrickson. Oxford: Oxford UP, 1966, 52.
Her pleasure pleasures to impart
In ling'ring pain, in death resign'd,
Her latest agony of mind
Was felt for him, who could not save
His All from an untimely grave:
7.1 - 10.6 In ... woe:] "In place of these lines, [...]" R. Lonsdale, 1969.
"In place of these lines, Bedingfield has:
To hide her Cares her only art,This variant is also recorded by Mason in 1775."The Poems of Thomas Gray, William Collins, Oliver Goldsmith. Edited by Roger Lonsdale. Longman Annotated English Poets Series. London and Harlow: Longmans, 1969, 209.
Her pleasure pleasures to impart.
In ling'ring pain, in death resign'd,
Her latest agony of mind
Was felt for him, who could not save
His All from an untimely grave:
7.1 - 10.6 In ... woe:] "Toynbee and Whibley, Corresp ii [...]" R. Lonsdale, 1969.
"Toynbee and Whibley, Corresp ii 560 n 7, mention John Clerke's copy of G[ray].'s 1768 Poems, in which he had transcribed this poem, as 'Epitaph on Mrs --- who died in Childbirth, by Mr Gray'. G. may not at first have known the manner of Mrs Clerke's death and have decided later to introduce a reference to the child in his revised version of these lines."
The Poems of Thomas Gray, William Collins, Oliver Goldsmith. Edited by Roger Lonsdale. Longman Annotated English Poets Series. London and Harlow: Longmans, 1969, 209.7.1 - 10.6 In ... woe:] "''To hide her cares her [...]" E. Gosse, 1884.
"''To hide her cares her only art,The Works of Thomas Gray: In Prose and Verse. Ed. by Edmund Gosse, in four vols. London: MacMillan and Co., 1884, vol. i, 126/127.
Her pleasure, pleasures to impart,
In ling'ring pain, in death resign'd
Her latest agony of mind
Was felt for him, who could not save
His all from an untimely grave.'' - MS."
7.1 - 10.6 In ... woe:] "Mitford gives the six following [...]" J. Bradshaw, 1891.
"Mitford gives the six following lines as in a manuscript copy instead of lines 7 to 10 as finally decided on:—
"To hide her cares her only art,The Poetical Works of Thomas Gray: English and Latin. Edited with an introduction, life, notes and a bibliography by John Bradshaw. The Aldine edition of the British poets series. London: George Bell and sons, 1891, 256.
Her pleasure, pleasures to impart,
In ling'ring pain, in death resigned,
Her latest agony of mind
Was felt for him, who could not save
His all from an untimely grave.""
7.1 - 10.6 In ... woe:] "V. L. after l. 6 [...]" D.C. Tovey, 1922 [1st ed. 1898].
"V. L. after l. 6 in place of the four next:
''To hide her cares her only art,Gray's English Poems, Original and Translated from the Norse and Welsh. Edited by Duncan C. Tovey. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1922 [1st ed. 1898], 235.
Her pleasure, pleasures to impart,
In ling'ring pain, in death resign'd,
Her latest agony of mind
Was felt for him, who could not save
His All from an untimely grave.'' Mason."
7.1 - 8.7 In ... behind.] "In the wife's solicitude about [...]" D.C. Tovey, 1922 [1st ed. 1898].
"In the wife's solicitude about her husband's pain, as Gray expresses it in the text,
''In agony, in death resign'dthere is such an allusiveness as the difference of circumstances permitted to the words of Arria to Paetus, when she hands him the sword, in Martial (i. 14)
She felt the wound she left behind,''
''Si qua fides, volnus, quod feci non dolet, inquit,Gray's English Poems, Original and Translated from the Norse and Welsh. Edited by Duncan C. Tovey. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1922 [1st ed. 1898], 235.
Sed quod tu facies, hoc mihi Paete dolet.''
['' 'Tis not the wound that I have made, said she,
But that which thou wilt make, that paineth me.'']"
7.1 - 10.6 In ... woe:] "Variant[] [...] from the Bedingfield [...]" A.L. Poole/L. Whibley, 1950 [1st ed. 1919].
"Variant[] [...] from the Bedingfield MS. Mason, in a note to the poem, gives the following lines as a MS. variation 'after line 6, in the place of the four next'.
To hide her cares her only art,The Poems of Gray and Collins. Edited by Austin Lane Poole. Revised by Leonard Whibley. Third edition. Oxford editions of standard authors series. London: Oxford UP, 1937, reprinted 1950 [1st ed. 1919], 177.
Her pleasure, pleasures to impart,
In ling'ring pain, in death resign'd,
Her latest agony of mind
Was felt for him, who could not save
His All from an untimely grave:"
7.1 - 10.6 In ... woe:] "To hide her cares her [...]" H.W. Starr/J.R. Hendrickson, 1966.
"To hide her cares her only art,Bed[ingfield MS.], also noted as variant in M[ason]."The Complete Poems of Thomas Gray: English, Latin and Greek. Edited by Herbert W. Starr and J. R. Hendrickson. Oxford: Oxford UP, 1966, 52.
Her pleasure pleasures to impart
In ling'ring pain, in death resign'd,
Her latest agony of mind
Was felt for him, who could not save
His All from an untimely grave:
7.1 - 10.6 In ... woe:] "In place of these lines, [...]" R. Lonsdale, 1969.
"In place of these lines, Bedingfield has:
To hide her Cares her only art,This variant is also recorded by Mason in 1775."The Poems of Thomas Gray, William Collins, Oliver Goldsmith. Edited by Roger Lonsdale. Longman Annotated English Poets Series. London and Harlow: Longmans, 1969, 209.
Her pleasure pleasures to impart.
In ling'ring pain, in death resign'd,
Her latest agony of mind
Was felt for him, who could not save
His All from an untimely grave:
7.1 - 10.6 In ... woe:] "Toynbee and Whibley, Corresp ii [...]" R. Lonsdale, 1969.
"Toynbee and Whibley, Corresp ii 560 n 7, mention John Clerke's copy of G[ray].'s 1768 Poems, in which he had transcribed this poem, as 'Epitaph on Mrs --- who died in Childbirth, by Mr Gray'. G. may not at first have known the manner of Mrs Clerke's death and have decided later to introduce a reference to the child in his revised version of these lines."
The Poems of Thomas Gray, William Collins, Oliver Goldsmith. Edited by Roger Lonsdale. Longman Annotated English Poets Series. London and Harlow: Longmans, 1969, 209.7.1 - 10.6 In ... woe:] "''To hide her cares her [...]" E. Gosse, 1884.
"''To hide her cares her only art,The Works of Thomas Gray: In Prose and Verse. Ed. by Edmund Gosse, in four vols. London: MacMillan and Co., 1884, vol. i, 126/127.
Her pleasure, pleasures to impart,
In ling'ring pain, in death resign'd
Her latest agony of mind
Was felt for him, who could not save
His all from an untimely grave.'' - MS."
7.1 - 10.6 In ... woe:] "Mitford gives the six following [...]" J. Bradshaw, 1891.
"Mitford gives the six following lines as in a manuscript copy instead of lines 7 to 10 as finally decided on:—
"To hide her cares her only art,The Poetical Works of Thomas Gray: English and Latin. Edited with an introduction, life, notes and a bibliography by John Bradshaw. The Aldine edition of the British poets series. London: George Bell and sons, 1891, 256.
Her pleasure, pleasures to impart,
In ling'ring pain, in death resigned,
Her latest agony of mind
Was felt for him, who could not save
His all from an untimely grave.""
7.1 - 10.6 In ... woe:] "V. L. after l. 6 [...]" D.C. Tovey, 1922 [1st ed. 1898].
"V. L. after l. 6 in place of the four next:
''To hide her cares her only art,Gray's English Poems, Original and Translated from the Norse and Welsh. Edited by Duncan C. Tovey. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1922 [1st ed. 1898], 235.
Her pleasure, pleasures to impart,
In ling'ring pain, in death resign'd,
Her latest agony of mind
Was felt for him, who could not save
His All from an untimely grave.'' Mason."
7.1 - 10.6 In ... woe:] "Variant[] [...] from the Bedingfield [...]" A.L. Poole/L. Whibley, 1950 [1st ed. 1919].
"Variant[] [...] from the Bedingfield MS. Mason, in a note to the poem, gives the following lines as a MS. variation 'after line 6, in the place of the four next'.
To hide her cares her only art,The Poems of Gray and Collins. Edited by Austin Lane Poole. Revised by Leonard Whibley. Third edition. Oxford editions of standard authors series. London: Oxford UP, 1937, reprinted 1950 [1st ed. 1919], 177.
Her pleasure, pleasures to impart,
In ling'ring pain, in death resign'd,
Her latest agony of mind
Was felt for him, who could not save
His All from an untimely grave:"
7.1 - 10.6 In ... woe:] "To hide her cares her [...]" H.W. Starr/J.R. Hendrickson, 1966.
"To hide her cares her only art,Bed[ingfield MS.], also noted as variant in M[ason]."The Complete Poems of Thomas Gray: English, Latin and Greek. Edited by Herbert W. Starr and J. R. Hendrickson. Oxford: Oxford UP, 1966, 52.
Her pleasure pleasures to impart
In ling'ring pain, in death resign'd,
Her latest agony of mind
Was felt for him, who could not save
His All from an untimely grave:
7.1 - 10.6 In ... woe:] "In place of these lines, [...]" R. Lonsdale, 1969.
"In place of these lines, Bedingfield has:
To hide her Cares her only art,This variant is also recorded by Mason in 1775."The Poems of Thomas Gray, William Collins, Oliver Goldsmith. Edited by Roger Lonsdale. Longman Annotated English Poets Series. London and Harlow: Longmans, 1969, 209.
Her pleasure pleasures to impart.
In ling'ring pain, in death resign'd,
Her latest agony of mind
Was felt for him, who could not save
His All from an untimely grave:
7.1 - 10.6 In ... woe:] "Toynbee and Whibley, Corresp ii [...]" R. Lonsdale, 1969.
"Toynbee and Whibley, Corresp ii 560 n 7, mention John Clerke's copy of G[ray].'s 1768 Poems, in which he had transcribed this poem, as 'Epitaph on Mrs --- who died in Childbirth, by Mr Gray'. G. may not at first have known the manner of Mrs Clerke's death and have decided later to introduce a reference to the child in his revised version of these lines."
The Poems of Thomas Gray, William Collins, Oliver Goldsmith. Edited by Roger Lonsdale. Longman Annotated English Poets Series. London and Harlow: Longmans, 1969, 209.9.1-5 Her ... below,] "Mrs. Clarke died in childbirth, [...]" J. Bradshaw, 1891.
"Mrs. Clarke died in childbirth, but the infant survived her."
The Poetical Works of Thomas Gray: English and Latin. Edited with an introduction, life, notes and a bibliography by John Bradshaw. The Aldine edition of the British poets series. London: George Bell and sons, 1891, 256.9.1 - 10.6 Her ... woe:] "Dr Bradshaw says here that [...]" D.C. Tovey, 1922 [1st ed. 1898].
"Dr Bradshaw says here that Mrs Clarke died in childbirth. I can find no evidence for this, except the statement of Mr Gosse. It is certainly no proper inference from these two lines, and that Gray should have made no use of a fact which lent itself so easily to pathos*, [*Footnote: Cf. the following epitaph on a lady who did die in child-birth, the child surviving her: ''I, quaere, lector, an non sit lucrum mori, / Quum moriens mater vitam dat et accipit / Mortalem nato, aeternam sibi.''] is almost inconceivable. But it is clear from the preceding note that in the first draft of the verses he had forgotten the existence of the child altogether; and if the circumstances were as Mr Gosse represents them, this should have the distinction of being quite the worst epitaph ever written by a poet of name. As it is, the sentiment of the last two lines, whatever we may think of it, is not Christian; and of even pagan poets not all would affirm that time, when it puts an end to life, puts an end to memory and to love."
Gray's English Poems, Original and Translated from the Norse and Welsh. Edited by Duncan C. Tovey. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1922 [1st ed. 1898], 235.7.1 - 10.6 In ... woe:] "''To hide her cares her [...]" E. Gosse, 1884.
"''To hide her cares her only art,The Works of Thomas Gray: In Prose and Verse. Ed. by Edmund Gosse, in four vols. London: MacMillan and Co., 1884, vol. i, 126/127.
Her pleasure, pleasures to impart,
In ling'ring pain, in death resign'd
Her latest agony of mind
Was felt for him, who could not save
His all from an untimely grave.'' - MS."
7.1 - 10.6 In ... woe:] "Mitford gives the six following [...]" J. Bradshaw, 1891.
"Mitford gives the six following lines as in a manuscript copy instead of lines 7 to 10 as finally decided on:—
"To hide her cares her only art,The Poetical Works of Thomas Gray: English and Latin. Edited with an introduction, life, notes and a bibliography by John Bradshaw. The Aldine edition of the British poets series. London: George Bell and sons, 1891, 256.
Her pleasure, pleasures to impart,
In ling'ring pain, in death resigned,
Her latest agony of mind
Was felt for him, who could not save
His all from an untimely grave.""
7.1 - 10.6 In ... woe:] "V. L. after l. 6 [...]" D.C. Tovey, 1922 [1st ed. 1898].
"V. L. after l. 6 in place of the four next:
''To hide her cares her only art,Gray's English Poems, Original and Translated from the Norse and Welsh. Edited by Duncan C. Tovey. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1922 [1st ed. 1898], 235.
Her pleasure, pleasures to impart,
In ling'ring pain, in death resign'd,
Her latest agony of mind
Was felt for him, who could not save
His All from an untimely grave.'' Mason."
7.1 - 10.6 In ... woe:] "Variant[] [...] from the Bedingfield [...]" A.L. Poole/L. Whibley, 1950 [1st ed. 1919].
"Variant[] [...] from the Bedingfield MS. Mason, in a note to the poem, gives the following lines as a MS. variation 'after line 6, in the place of the four next'.
To hide her cares her only art,The Poems of Gray and Collins. Edited by Austin Lane Poole. Revised by Leonard Whibley. Third edition. Oxford editions of standard authors series. London: Oxford UP, 1937, reprinted 1950 [1st ed. 1919], 177.
Her pleasure, pleasures to impart,
In ling'ring pain, in death resign'd,
Her latest agony of mind
Was felt for him, who could not save
His All from an untimely grave:"
7.1 - 10.6 In ... woe:] "To hide her cares her [...]" H.W. Starr/J.R. Hendrickson, 1966.
"To hide her cares her only art,Bed[ingfield MS.], also noted as variant in M[ason]."The Complete Poems of Thomas Gray: English, Latin and Greek. Edited by Herbert W. Starr and J. R. Hendrickson. Oxford: Oxford UP, 1966, 52.
Her pleasure pleasures to impart
In ling'ring pain, in death resign'd,
Her latest agony of mind
Was felt for him, who could not save
His All from an untimely grave:
7.1 - 10.6 In ... woe:] "In place of these lines, [...]" R. Lonsdale, 1969.
"In place of these lines, Bedingfield has:
To hide her Cares her only art,This variant is also recorded by Mason in 1775."The Poems of Thomas Gray, William Collins, Oliver Goldsmith. Edited by Roger Lonsdale. Longman Annotated English Poets Series. London and Harlow: Longmans, 1969, 209.
Her pleasure pleasures to impart.
In ling'ring pain, in death resign'd,
Her latest agony of mind
Was felt for him, who could not save
His All from an untimely grave:
7.1 - 10.6 In ... woe:] "Toynbee and Whibley, Corresp ii [...]" R. Lonsdale, 1969.
"Toynbee and Whibley, Corresp ii 560 n 7, mention John Clerke's copy of G[ray].'s 1768 Poems, in which he had transcribed this poem, as 'Epitaph on Mrs --- who died in Childbirth, by Mr Gray'. G. may not at first have known the manner of Mrs Clerke's death and have decided later to introduce a reference to the child in his revised version of these lines."
The Poems of Thomas Gray, William Collins, Oliver Goldsmith. Edited by Roger Lonsdale. Longman Annotated English Poets Series. London and Harlow: Longmans, 1969, 209.9.1 - 10.6 Her ... woe:] "Dr Bradshaw says here that [...]" D.C. Tovey, 1922 [1st ed. 1898].
"Dr Bradshaw says here that Mrs Clarke died in childbirth. I can find no evidence for this, except the statement of Mr Gosse. It is certainly no proper inference from these two lines, and that Gray should have made no use of a fact which lent itself so easily to pathos*, [*Footnote: Cf. the following epitaph on a lady who did die in child-birth, the child surviving her: ''I, quaere, lector, an non sit lucrum mori, / Quum moriens mater vitam dat et accipit / Mortalem nato, aeternam sibi.''] is almost inconceivable. But it is clear from the preceding note that in the first draft of the verses he had forgotten the existence of the child altogether; and if the circumstances were as Mr Gosse represents them, this should have the distinction of being quite the worst epitaph ever written by a poet of name. As it is, the sentiment of the last two lines, whatever we may think of it, is not Christian; and of even pagan poets not all would affirm that time, when it puts an end to life, puts an end to memory and to love."
Gray's English Poems, Original and Translated from the Norse and Welsh. Edited by Duncan C. Tovey. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1922 [1st ed. 1898], 235.11.1 - 12.6 Whom ... days?] "Cp. Elegy 74-5 (p. 131)." R. Lonsdale, 1969.
"Cp. Elegy 74-5 (p. 131)."
The Poems of Thomas Gray, William Collins, Oliver Goldsmith. Edited by Roger Lonsdale. Longman Annotated English Poets Series. London and Harlow: Longmans, 1969, 209.11.1 - 12.6 Whom ... days?] "Cp. Elegy 74-5 (p. 131)." R. Lonsdale, 1969.
"Cp. Elegy 74-5 (p. 131)."
The Poems of Thomas Gray, William Collins, Oliver Goldsmith. Edited by Roger Lonsdale. Longman Annotated English Poets Series. London and Harlow: Longmans, 1969, 209.13.4 secret] "silent Bed[ingfield MS.]." H.W. Starr/J.R. Hendrickson, 1966.
"silent Bed[ingfield MS.]."
The Complete Poems of Thomas Gray: English, Latin and Greek. Edited by Herbert W. Starr and J. R. Hendrickson. Oxford: Oxford UP, 1966, 52.13.4 secret] "silent Bedingfield." R. Lonsdale, 1969.
"silent Bedingfield."
The Poems of Thomas Gray, William Collins, Oliver Goldsmith. Edited by Roger Lonsdale. Longman Annotated English Poets Series. London and Harlow: Longmans, 1969, 209.Works cited
- The Poetical Works of Thomas Gray: English and Latin. Edited with an introduction, life, notes and a bibliography by John Bradshaw. The Aldine edition of the British poets series. London: George Bell and sons, 1891.
- The Works of Thomas Gray: In Prose and Verse. Ed. by Edmund Gosse, in four vols. London: MacMillan and Co., 1884, vol. i.
- Thomas Gray: Selected Poems. Ed. by John Heath-Stubbs. Manchester: Carcanet New Press Ltd., 1981.
- The Poems of Thomas Gray, William Collins, Oliver Goldsmith. Edited by Roger Lonsdale. Longman Annotated English Poets Series. London and Harlow: Longmans, 1969.
- The Poems of Gray and Collins. Edited by Austin Lane Poole. Revised by Leonard Whibley. Third edition. Oxford editions of standard authors series. London: Oxford UP, 1937, reprinted 1950 [1st ed. 1919].
- The Complete English Poems of Thomas Gray. Edited with an Introduction and Notes by James Reeves. The Poetry Bookshelf series. London: Heinemann; New York: Barnes & Noble, 1973.
- The Complete Poems of Thomas Gray: English, Latin and Greek. Edited by Herbert W. Starr and J. R. Hendrickson. Oxford: Oxford UP, 1966.
- Gray's English Poems, Original and Translated from the Norse and Welsh. Edited by Duncan C. Tovey. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1922 [1st ed. 1898].
Spelling has been modernized throughout, except in case of conscious archaisms. Contractions, italics and initial capitalization have been largely eliminated, except where of real import. Obvious errors have been silently corrected, punctuation has been supplied. The editor would like to express his gratitude to the library staff of the Göttingen State and University Library (SUB Göttingen) for their invaluable assistance.